The graphics looks superb, but (there's always but ;-)

• No progress bar. When you wait for ~20-30 seconds,
  you need it because otherwise people don't know if
  it's stuck or advancing.


• The option in rhgb to view details was important
  IMO.

Thanks for the work, rhgb indeed look a bit clumsy (speed,
occasional flicker during modesetting, etc.)

The intended progress bar is the spinning infinity -- we'll have to see how people end up reacting to it :) The thing that's hard about a progress bar is you don't know how long various steps will take.

As far as viewing details, you can press escape and all the boot messages will appear. Escape again and you're back to purtiness.

Looks great. Kudos.
What about the shutdown screen?

There's still a lot to do to finish getting startup nice -- and then the better answer for shutdown might be just to make it fast enough not to matter

Hey, that's wonderful!

The animation is pretty nice, and having a flicker free boot on my macbook is a dream :-)

Thanks a lot for the work!

Do we have to kill and start a new X for GDM, with that texty "login" prompt? Looks bad

As listed on the feature page, one of the outstanding things to do is to get X reusing the existing mode and start on the same vt. Which requires that we actually be using the modesetting drivers rather than (ab)using framebuffer drivers.

Hopefully the basic modesetting support will be landing in the rawhide kernel this week or early next for Intel hardware and then some of those sorts of issues will get ironed out.

great. thanks. now only if it'd boot faster ;)

btw. what about suspend to disk splashes etc.?

Yeah, my boot has drastically slowed down again in the past week or two but I haven't had a chance to sit down and find the bottleneck. We're probably starting a bunch of new services tha twe shouldn't

As far as suspend to disk, it's something that's on the list to look at, but realistically, I suspect that there's not going to be time before F10 to get it hooked up nicely. I could be shown to be wrong, though.

we're working on it. :)

improving boot speed, that is.

There are some Fedora bootcharts on https://wiki.ubuntu.com/BootCharting#head-dca0372aa8fd490a9717ad0c72c9b400c236a581 . Here's hoping that they might help...

I like very much the new infinity spinner.
If let's say it takes too long to boot and I press ESC (as suggested in previous comments) should I be able to see what is taking so long and if the boot is stalled ?
If yes - I am positively sure that the new spinner will be greatly accepted instead of the progress bar.

Yep, pressing escape will show you the buffer of all of the text which has been displayed up to that point.

Will Plymouth accept input ?

Or will it miserably crash as RHGB when the password for mounting cyphered partitions is asked ?

Looks great anyway.